Re: Unnecessary verbiage that wastes my time
Regarding Discord, I recently created a server for discussing all things audio, but it has been suggested that I create specific areas for the NVDA and JAWS communities. So the groundwork is already there. If anyone wants to join the server or wants to express their interest in such an area, please contact me off list.
|
|
Re: Unnecessary verbiage that wastes my time
I might be interested in putting in my two cents on this topic. Shouldn't the NVDA community have a Discord server or something by now, though? Email lists are a bit old-school at this point.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
On 8/08/2020 1:35 am, Gene wrote: I don't know who is interested in the topic of what is announced during web page navigation but I'm going to start a topic on what is helpful and useful and what is just clutter on the chat list so those interested may want to join. The chat list is a low traffic list.
Gene -----Original Message----- From: Joseph Lee Sent: Friday, August 07, 2020 10:21 AM To: nvda@nvda.groups.io Subject: Re: [nvda] Unnecessary verbiage that wastes my time
Hi, It's a combination of user expectations, what document writers wrote, and specifications. In case of "figure/out of figure", it's more towards ARIA specs, how web authors wrote their sites 9including which framework is in use), and how NVDA got such an information. Cheers, Joseph
-----Original Message----- From: nvda@nvda.groups.io <nvda@nvda.groups.io> On Behalf Of Gene Sent: Friday, August 7, 2020 8:19 AM To: nvda@nvda.groups.io Subject: Re: [nvda] Unnecessary verbiage that wastes my time
I should clarify, based on what Brian said, that I don't object to the text being read in this instance or in general. I object to figure and out of figure being announced . Just as I object to announcement of bloc quotes being on. Its not the text being read I object to but people in general don't benefit from hearing such information. It seems to me that the designers should consider what is useful infrmation in terms of navigating and in terms of what people generally use when determining what should be announced by default. I don't know how they determine what is announced.
Gene -----Original Message----- From: Felix G. Sent: Friday, August 07, 2020 9:46 AM To: nvda@nvda.groups.io Subject: Re: [nvda] Unnecessary verbiage that wastes my time
Hi! I've been reading along and I know this feeling. I often refer to it as the user experience that nobody designed. On the one hand there's a screen reader developer, on the other there's an app developer or web designer. They don't know each other, and yet their decisions converge on our experience of their products. In the sighted world nobody would get away with it, but we get translations of translations, almost never what someone consciously designed. Best, Felix
Am Do., 6. Aug. 2020 um 17:58 Uhr schrieb Brian Vogel <britechguy@gmail.com>:
On Thu, Aug 6, 2020 at 10:34 AM, Gene wrote:
People would never put up with a human reader announcing all this clutter.
I'd say that's absolutely true, but they'd probably also expect a human reader to say something about the fact that there is a figure/image present and what it illustrates as a part of the reading, unless the person their reading for has explicitly requested they only read the main text.
I actually feel your pain, and have had exactly that same feeling many, many times with multiple screen readers. I hope that someday there arrives AI sophisticated enough to screen read the way "your average sighted person" would likely take in looking at content. Heaven knows we virtually never look at scads of the navigation links and the like at the outset, but the main page content first.
But at this point in time, since a screen reader itself has no idea, really, of what it is you (any you) are looking for on a given page it offers "way too much" rather than allowing you to possibly miss the presence of something.
It would be nice if all of these sorts of things were arranged in "chunks" of announcements that fit a certain class, and that you could have the option of turning off the entire class with one checkbox, or going through the individual things announced and unchecking the ones you explicitly don't want while retaining the others. And do I ever know what a PITA that would be to code, and for the user to slog through, but in any really complex system where a high level of customization is wanted or needed, this is how its obtained.
--
Brian - Windows 10 Pro, 64-Bit, Version 1909, Build 18363
A gentleman is one who never hurts anyone's feelings unintentionally.
~ Oscar Wilde
|
|
I'll send it.
Its good to know the problem isn't a fault with NVDA.
Gene
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
-----Original Message----- From: Greg Williams Sent: Friday, August 07, 2020 2:43 PM To: nvda@nvda.groups.io Subject: Re: [nvda] A possible bug That would be fine with me. Also I forgot to say that I verified that removing the aria-label from the link did allow NVDA to see the h2 tag as it does in the other links. Greg On 8/7/2020 3:28 PM, Gene wrote: I'm not sure if I have the technical knowledge to present this to The Times. Do you object if I forward part of your remarks that describe the problem?
Gene -----Original Message----- From: Greg Williams Sent: Friday, August 07, 2020 2:02 PM To: nvda@nvda.groups.io Subject: Re: [nvda] A possible bug
It is an issue with the HTML. For whatever reason, they coded the links under the opinion section differently than the rest of the links. They used accessibility badly which made it worse than if they had done nothing. In the opinion section, the put an aria-label on the <a> tag for the link; this tells assistive technology to ignore any other text in the link. The h2 tag is wrapped inside the <a> tag which means that it also gets ignored by the assitive technology.
I imagine that the reason the old version of NVDA detected the headings is that it is old enough that it did not handle aria-labels and so just ignored them and picked up the nested content including the h2. I will stop here and refrain from giving my opinion on the coding practices in the webpage.
Greg
On 8/6/2020 9:46 PM, Gene wrote:
I haven't asked The Times. I thought it was a problem with NVDA since mhy old version recognizes them as headings. I haven't used JAWS to any extent for years but it might be useful for someone using a current JAWS to see if these links are seen as headings.
Gene -----Original Message----- From: Gene Sent: Thursday, August 06, 2020 8:42 PM To: nvda@nvda.groups.io Subject: Re: [nvda] A possible bug
When I use a very old version of NVDA, they are reported as headings when I move from heading to heading with report headings turned on. I don't know what the last version was that this occurs. I can also move to the articles when using filter by headings in the elements list of the old version.
I don't know how old a version of NVDA needs to be used. I use Windows 7 and I still use 13.x much of the time because it does almost everything I want. I play around with new versions at times.
All other articles on the page are reported as headings in the new NVDA. So why aren't these and how often, on other pages, may material be being missed?
Evidently, there is something different about these headings but what?
Gene -----Original Message----- From: Quentin Christensen Sent: Thursday, August 06, 2020 8:27 PM To: nvda@nvda.groups.io Subject: Re: [nvda] A possible bug
Hi Gene,
It looks like those articles aren't marked up as headings. If you go to the Opinion heading, you can then press TAB or K to go to the links for the pieces, but they aren't reported as headings. Looking in the elements list, I can find them in the links but not headings.
Pages like the New York Times are quite complex and it's likely something has been missed somewhere along the line. What did the NYT people have to say?
Quentin.
On Fri, Aug 7, 2020 at 8:24 AM Gene <gsasner@gmail.com> wrote: I'm using the latest beta, I haven't switched to the production version.
This appears to be a bug and it may result in information being missed. On The New York Times home page, using Firefox or Brave, I haven't yet tested with Chrome, but Brave is Chrome-based, when you get to the opinion part of the page, the articles in that section aren't seen as headings. All other articles are seen as headings and using a very old NVDA, the articles in the opinion section are seen as headings. This is using Windows 7.
I just tested with NVDA 2019.2.21 and the same thing happens so this likely bug has been around for some time.
I also just tested with Chrome and the same thing occurs. All articles in the opinion section are skipped and the screen-reader moves directly to the editor's picks heading. It needs to be determined what is causing this problem and that may help determine its seriousness.
Gene
|
|
That would be fine with me. Also I forgot to say that I verified that removing the aria-label from the link did allow NVDA to see the h2 tag as it does in the other links.
Greg
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
On 8/7/2020 3:28 PM, Gene wrote: I'm not sure if I have the technical knowledge to present this to The Times. Do you object if I forward part of your remarks that describe the problem?
Gene -----Original Message----- From: Greg Williams Sent: Friday, August 07, 2020 2:02 PM To: nvda@nvda.groups.io Subject: Re: [nvda] A possible bug
It is an issue with the HTML. For whatever reason, they coded the links under the opinion section differently than the rest of the links. They used accessibility badly which made it worse than if they had done nothing. In the opinion section, the put an aria-label on the <a> tag for the link; this tells assistive technology to ignore any other text in the link. The h2 tag is wrapped inside the <a> tag which means that it also gets ignored by the assitive technology.
I imagine that the reason the old version of NVDA detected the headings is that it is old enough that it did not handle aria-labels and so just ignored them and picked up the nested content including the h2. I will stop here and refrain from giving my opinion on the coding practices in the webpage.
Greg
On 8/6/2020 9:46 PM, Gene wrote:
I haven't asked The Times. I thought it was a problem with NVDA since mhy old version recognizes them as headings. I haven't used JAWS to any extent for years but it might be useful for someone using a current JAWS to see if these links are seen as headings.
Gene -----Original Message----- From: Gene Sent: Thursday, August 06, 2020 8:42 PM To: nvda@nvda.groups.io Subject: Re: [nvda] A possible bug
When I use a very old version of NVDA, they are reported as headings when I move from heading to heading with report headings turned on. I don't know what the last version was that this occurs. I can also move to the articles when using filter by headings in the elements list of the old version.
I don't know how old a version of NVDA needs to be used. I use Windows 7 and I still use 13.x much of the time because it does almost everything I want. I play around with new versions at times.
All other articles on the page are reported as headings in the new NVDA. So why aren't these and how often, on other pages, may material be being missed?
Evidently, there is something different about these headings but what?
Gene -----Original Message----- From: Quentin Christensen Sent: Thursday, August 06, 2020 8:27 PM To: nvda@nvda.groups.io Subject: Re: [nvda] A possible bug
Hi Gene,
It looks like those articles aren't marked up as headings. If you go to the Opinion heading, you can then press TAB or K to go to the links for the pieces, but they aren't reported as headings. Looking in the elements list, I can find them in the links but not headings.
Pages like the New York Times are quite complex and it's likely something has been missed somewhere along the line. What did the NYT people have to say?
Quentin.
On Fri, Aug 7, 2020 at 8:24 AM Gene <gsasner@gmail.com> wrote: I'm using the latest beta, I haven't switched to the production version.
This appears to be a bug and it may result in information being missed. On The New York Times home page, using Firefox or Brave, I haven't yet tested with Chrome, but Brave is Chrome-based, when you get to the opinion part of the page, the articles in that section aren't seen as headings. All other articles are seen as headings and using a very old NVDA, the articles in the opinion section are seen as headings. This is using Windows 7.
I just tested with NVDA 2019.2.21 and the same thing happens so this likely bug has been around for some time.
I also just tested with Chrome and the same thing occurs. All articles in the opinion section are skipped and the screen-reader moves directly to the editor's picks heading. It needs to be determined what is causing this problem and that may help determine its seriousness.
Gene
|
|
I'm not sure if I have the technical knowledge to present this to The Times. Do you object if I forward part of your remarks that describe the problem?
Gene
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
-----Original Message----- From: Greg Williams Sent: Friday, August 07, 2020 2:02 PM To: nvda@nvda.groups.io Subject: Re: [nvda] A possible bug It is an issue with the HTML. For whatever reason, they coded the links under the opinion section differently than the rest of the links. They used accessibility badly which made it worse than if they had done nothing. In the opinion section, the put an aria-label on the <a> tag for the link; this tells assistive technology to ignore any other text in the link. The h2 tag is wrapped inside the <a> tag which means that it also gets ignored by the assitive technology. I imagine that the reason the old version of NVDA detected the headings is that it is old enough that it did not handle aria-labels and so just ignored them and picked up the nested content including the h2. I will stop here and refrain from giving my opinion on the coding practices in the webpage. Greg On 8/6/2020 9:46 PM, Gene wrote: I haven't asked The Times. I thought it was a problem with NVDA since mhy old version recognizes them as headings. I haven't used JAWS to any extent for years but it might be useful for someone using a current JAWS to see if these links are seen as headings.
Gene -----Original Message----- From: Gene Sent: Thursday, August 06, 2020 8:42 PM To: nvda@nvda.groups.io Subject: Re: [nvda] A possible bug
When I use a very old version of NVDA, they are reported as headings when I move from heading to heading with report headings turned on. I don't know what the last version was that this occurs. I can also move to the articles when using filter by headings in the elements list of the old version.
I don't know how old a version of NVDA needs to be used. I use Windows 7 and I still use 13.x much of the time because it does almost everything I want. I play around with new versions at times.
All other articles on the page are reported as headings in the new NVDA. So why aren't these and how often, on other pages, may material be being missed?
Evidently, there is something different about these headings but what?
Gene -----Original Message----- From: Quentin Christensen Sent: Thursday, August 06, 2020 8:27 PM To: nvda@nvda.groups.io Subject: Re: [nvda] A possible bug
Hi Gene,
It looks like those articles aren't marked up as headings. If you go to the Opinion heading, you can then press TAB or K to go to the links for the pieces, but they aren't reported as headings. Looking in the elements list, I can find them in the links but not headings.
Pages like the New York Times are quite complex and it's likely something has been missed somewhere along the line. What did the NYT people have to say?
Quentin.
On Fri, Aug 7, 2020 at 8:24 AM Gene <gsasner@gmail.com> wrote: I'm using the latest beta, I haven't switched to the production version.
This appears to be a bug and it may result in information being missed. On The New York Times home page, using Firefox or Brave, I haven't yet tested with Chrome, but Brave is Chrome-based, when you get to the opinion part of the page, the articles in that section aren't seen as headings. All other articles are seen as headings and using a very old NVDA, the articles in the opinion section are seen as headings. This is using Windows 7.
I just tested with NVDA 2019.2.21 and the same thing happens so this likely bug has been around for some time.
I also just tested with Chrome and the same thing occurs. All articles in the opinion section are skipped and the screen-reader moves directly to the editor's picks heading. It needs to be determined what is causing this problem and that may help determine its seriousness.
Gene
|
|
It is an issue with the HTML. For whatever reason, they coded the links under the opinion section differently than the rest of the links. They used accessibility badly which made it worse than if they had done nothing. In the opinion section, the put an aria-label on the <a> tag for the link; this tells assistive technology to ignore any other text in the link. The h2 tag is wrapped inside the <a> tag which means that it also gets ignored by the assitive technology.
I imagine that the reason the old version of NVDA detected the headings is that it is old enough that it did not handle aria-labels and so just ignored them and picked up the nested content including the h2. I will stop here and refrain from giving my opinion on the coding practices in the webpage.
Greg
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
On 8/6/2020 9:46 PM, Gene wrote: I haven't asked The Times. I thought it was a problem with NVDA since mhy old version recognizes them as headings. I haven't used JAWS to any extent for years but it might be useful for someone using a current JAWS to see if these links are seen as headings.
Gene -----Original Message----- From: Gene Sent: Thursday, August 06, 2020 8:42 PM To: nvda@nvda.groups.io Subject: Re: [nvda] A possible bug
When I use a very old version of NVDA, they are reported as headings when I move from heading to heading with report headings turned on. I don't know what the last version was that this occurs. I can also move to the articles when using filter by headings in the elements list of the old version.
I don't know how old a version of NVDA needs to be used. I use Windows 7 and I still use 13.x much of the time because it does almost everything I want. I play around with new versions at times.
All other articles on the page are reported as headings in the new NVDA. So why aren't these and how often, on other pages, may material be being missed?
Evidently, there is something different about these headings but what?
Gene -----Original Message----- From: Quentin Christensen Sent: Thursday, August 06, 2020 8:27 PM To: nvda@nvda.groups.io Subject: Re: [nvda] A possible bug
Hi Gene,
It looks like those articles aren't marked up as headings. If you go to the Opinion heading, you can then press TAB or K to go to the links for the pieces, but they aren't reported as headings. Looking in the elements list, I can find them in the links but not headings.
Pages like the New York Times are quite complex and it's likely something has been missed somewhere along the line. What did the NYT people have to say?
Quentin.
On Fri, Aug 7, 2020 at 8:24 AM Gene <gsasner@gmail.com> wrote: I'm using the latest beta, I haven't switched to the production version.
This appears to be a bug and it may result in information being missed. On The New York Times home page, using Firefox or Brave, I haven't yet tested with Chrome, but Brave is Chrome-based, when you get to the opinion part of the page, the articles in that section aren't seen as headings. All other articles are seen as headings and using a very old NVDA, the articles in the opinion section are seen as headings. This is using Windows 7.
I just tested with NVDA 2019.2.21 and the same thing happens so this likely bug has been around for some time.
I also just tested with Chrome and the same thing occurs. All articles in the opinion section are skipped and the screen-reader moves directly to the editor's picks heading. It needs to be determined what is causing this problem and that may help determine its seriousness.
Gene
|
|
|
|
Re: Unnecessary verbiage that wastes my time
CARLOS-ESTEBAN <carlosestebanpianista@...>
Hello.
Well, a possible option is use the reader mode of the browsers.
In Firefox and new Microsoft Edge press f9.
In Chrome, go to the page chrome://flags. In the edit box search,
write "reader mode" and press enter. After, press tab and enabled
this feature.
Restart Chrome and after you can press f6, and tab two times for
the button enable reader mode and press enter.
An other solution is use the add-on Virtual Revieu, but I dont
know if this addon work in web pages.
Regards.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
El 7/8/2020 a las 9:46, Felix G.
escribió:
Hi!
I've been reading along and I know this feeling. I often refer to it
as the user experience that nobody designed. On the one hand there's a
screen reader developer, on the other there's an app developer or web
designer. They don't know each other, and yet their decisions converge
on our experience of their products. In the sighted world nobody would
get away with it, but we get translations of translations, almost
never what someone consciously designed.
Best,
Felix
Am Do., 6. Aug. 2020 um 17:58 Uhr schrieb Brian Vogel <britechguy@...>:
On Thu, Aug 6, 2020 at 10:34 AM, Gene wrote:
People would never put up with a human reader announcing all this clutter.
I'd say that's absolutely true, but they'd probably also expect a human reader to say something about the fact that there is a figure/image present and what it illustrates as a part of the reading, unless the person their reading for has explicitly requested they only read the main text.
I actually feel your pain, and have had exactly that same feeling many, many times with multiple screen readers. I hope that someday there arrives AI sophisticated enough to screen read the way "your average sighted person" would likely take in looking at content. Heaven knows we virtually never look at scads of the navigation links and the like at the outset, but the main page content first.
But at this point in time, since a screen reader itself has no idea, really, of what it is you (any you) are looking for on a given page it offers "way too much" rather than allowing you to possibly miss the presence of something.
It would be nice if all of these sorts of things were arranged in "chunks" of announcements that fit a certain class, and that you could have the option of turning off the entire class with one checkbox, or going through the individual things announced and unchecking the ones you explicitly don't want while retaining the others. And do I ever know what a PITA that would be to code, and for the user to slog through, but in any really complex system where a high level of customization is wanted or needed, this is how its obtained.
--
Brian - Windows 10 Pro, 64-Bit, Version 1909, Build 18363
A gentleman is one who never hurts anyone's feelings unintentionally.
~ Oscar Wilde
--
Carlos Esteban Martínez Macías.
Músico (pianista) y también ayuda a usuarios ciegos con el uso
de lectores de pantalla y tecnología.
Experto certificado en el lector de pantalla NVDA.
Musicien (pianist) and also help to the blind people in the use
of screen readers and technology. Certified expert in the screen
reader NVDA.
|
|
Re: Unnecessary verbiage that wastes my time
I don't know who is interested in the topic of what is announced during web page navigation but I'm going to start a topic on what is helpful and useful and what is just clutter on the chat list so those interested may want to join. The chat list is a low traffic list.
Gene
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
-----Original Message----- From: Joseph Lee Sent: Friday, August 07, 2020 10:21 AM To: nvda@nvda.groups.io Subject: Re: [nvda] Unnecessary verbiage that wastes my time Hi, It's a combination of user expectations, what document writers wrote, and specifications. In case of "figure/out of figure", it's more towards ARIA specs, how web authors wrote their sites 9including which framework is in use), and how NVDA got such an information. Cheers, Joseph -----Original Message----- From: nvda@nvda.groups.io <nvda@nvda.groups.io> On Behalf Of Gene Sent: Friday, August 7, 2020 8:19 AM To: nvda@nvda.groups.io Subject: Re: [nvda] Unnecessary verbiage that wastes my time I should clarify, based on what Brian said, that I don't object to the text being read in this instance or in general. I object to figure and out of figure being announced . Just as I object to announcement of bloc quotes being on. Its not the text being read I object to but people in general don't benefit from hearing such information. It seems to me that the designers should consider what is useful infrmation in terms of navigating and in terms of what people generally use when determining what should be announced by default. I don't know how they determine what is announced. Gene -----Original Message----- From: Felix G. Sent: Friday, August 07, 2020 9:46 AM To: nvda@nvda.groups.io Subject: Re: [nvda] Unnecessary verbiage that wastes my time Hi! I've been reading along and I know this feeling. I often refer to it as the user experience that nobody designed. On the one hand there's a screen reader developer, on the other there's an app developer or web designer. They don't know each other, and yet their decisions converge on our experience of their products. In the sighted world nobody would get away with it, but we get translations of translations, almost never what someone consciously designed. Best, Felix Am Do., 6. Aug. 2020 um 17:58 Uhr schrieb Brian Vogel <britechguy@gmail.com>: On Thu, Aug 6, 2020 at 10:34 AM, Gene wrote:
People would never put up with a human reader announcing all this clutter.
I'd say that's absolutely true, but they'd probably also expect a human reader to say something about the fact that there is a figure/image present and what it illustrates as a part of the reading, unless the person their reading for has explicitly requested they only read the main text.
I actually feel your pain, and have had exactly that same feeling many, many times with multiple screen readers. I hope that someday there arrives AI sophisticated enough to screen read the way "your average sighted person" would likely take in looking at content. Heaven knows we virtually never look at scads of the navigation links and the like at the outset, but the main page content first.
But at this point in time, since a screen reader itself has no idea, really, of what it is you (any you) are looking for on a given page it offers "way too much" rather than allowing you to possibly miss the presence of something.
It would be nice if all of these sorts of things were arranged in "chunks" of announcements that fit a certain class, and that you could have the option of turning off the entire class with one checkbox, or going through the individual things announced and unchecking the ones you explicitly don't want while retaining the others. And do I ever know what a PITA that would be to code, and for the user to slog through, but in any really complex system where a high level of customization is wanted or needed, this is how its obtained.
--
Brian - Windows 10 Pro, 64-Bit, Version 1909, Build 18363
A gentleman is one who never hurts anyone's feelings unintentionally.
~ Oscar Wilde
|
|
Re: Unnecessary verbiage that wastes my time
Hi, It's a combination of user expectations, what document writers wrote, and specifications. In case of "figure/out of figure", it's more towards ARIA specs, how web authors wrote their sites 9including which framework is in use), and how NVDA got such an information. Cheers, Joseph
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
-----Original Message----- From: nvda@nvda.groups.io <nvda@nvda.groups.io> On Behalf Of Gene Sent: Friday, August 7, 2020 8:19 AM To: nvda@nvda.groups.io Subject: Re: [nvda] Unnecessary verbiage that wastes my time I should clarify, based on what Brian said, that I don't object to the text being read in this instance or in general. I object to figure and out of figure being announced . Just as I object to announcement of bloc quotes being on. Its not the text being read I object to but people in general don't benefit from hearing such information. It seems to me that the designers should consider what is useful infrmation in terms of navigating and in terms of what people generally use when determining what should be announced by default. I don't know how they determine what is announced. Gene -----Original Message----- From: Felix G. Sent: Friday, August 07, 2020 9:46 AM To: nvda@nvda.groups.io Subject: Re: [nvda] Unnecessary verbiage that wastes my time Hi! I've been reading along and I know this feeling. I often refer to it as the user experience that nobody designed. On the one hand there's a screen reader developer, on the other there's an app developer or web designer. They don't know each other, and yet their decisions converge on our experience of their products. In the sighted world nobody would get away with it, but we get translations of translations, almost never what someone consciously designed. Best, Felix Am Do., 6. Aug. 2020 um 17:58 Uhr schrieb Brian Vogel <britechguy@gmail.com>: On Thu, Aug 6, 2020 at 10:34 AM, Gene wrote:
People would never put up with a human reader announcing all this clutter.
I'd say that's absolutely true, but they'd probably also expect a human reader to say something about the fact that there is a figure/image present and what it illustrates as a part of the reading, unless the person their reading for has explicitly requested they only read the main text.
I actually feel your pain, and have had exactly that same feeling many, many times with multiple screen readers. I hope that someday there arrives AI sophisticated enough to screen read the way "your average sighted person" would likely take in looking at content. Heaven knows we virtually never look at scads of the navigation links and the like at the outset, but the main page content first.
But at this point in time, since a screen reader itself has no idea, really, of what it is you (any you) are looking for on a given page it offers "way too much" rather than allowing you to possibly miss the presence of something.
It would be nice if all of these sorts of things were arranged in "chunks" of announcements that fit a certain class, and that you could have the option of turning off the entire class with one checkbox, or going through the individual things announced and unchecking the ones you explicitly don't want while retaining the others. And do I ever know what a PITA that would be to code, and for the user to slog through, but in any really complex system where a high level of customization is wanted or needed, this is how its obtained.
--
Brian - Windows 10 Pro, 64-Bit, Version 1909, Build 18363
A gentleman is one who never hurts anyone's feelings unintentionally.
~ Oscar Wilde
|
|
Re: Unnecessary verbiage that wastes my time
I should clarify, based on what Brian said, that I don't object to the text being read in this instance or in general. I object to figure and out of figure being announced . Just as I object to announcement of bloc quotes being on. Its not the text being read I object to but people in general don't benefit from hearing such information. It seems to me that the designers should consider what is useful infrmation in terms of navigating and in terms of what people generally use when determining what should be announced by default. I don't know how they determine what is announced.
Gene
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
-----Original Message----- From: Felix G. Sent: Friday, August 07, 2020 9:46 AM To: nvda@nvda.groups.io Subject: Re: [nvda] Unnecessary verbiage that wastes my time Hi! I've been reading along and I know this feeling. I often refer to it as the user experience that nobody designed. On the one hand there's a screen reader developer, on the other there's an app developer or web designer. They don't know each other, and yet their decisions converge on our experience of their products. In the sighted world nobody would get away with it, but we get translations of translations, almost never what someone consciously designed. Best, Felix Am Do., 6. Aug. 2020 um 17:58 Uhr schrieb Brian Vogel <britechguy@gmail.com>: On Thu, Aug 6, 2020 at 10:34 AM, Gene wrote:
People would never put up with a human reader announcing all this clutter.
I'd say that's absolutely true, but they'd probably also expect a human reader to say something about the fact that there is a figure/image present and what it illustrates as a part of the reading, unless the person their reading for has explicitly requested they only read the main text.
I actually feel your pain, and have had exactly that same feeling many, many times with multiple screen readers. I hope that someday there arrives AI sophisticated enough to screen read the way "your average sighted person" would likely take in looking at content. Heaven knows we virtually never look at scads of the navigation links and the like at the outset, but the main page content first.
But at this point in time, since a screen reader itself has no idea, really, of what it is you (any you) are looking for on a given page it offers "way too much" rather than allowing you to possibly miss the presence of something.
It would be nice if all of these sorts of things were arranged in "chunks" of announcements that fit a certain class, and that you could have the option of turning off the entire class with one checkbox, or going through the individual things announced and unchecking the ones you explicitly don't want while retaining the others. And do I ever know what a PITA that would be to code, and for the user to slog through, but in any really complex system where a high level of customization is wanted or needed, this is how its obtained.
--
Brian - Windows 10 Pro, 64-Bit, Version 1909, Build 18363
A gentleman is one who never hurts anyone's feelings unintentionally.
~ Oscar Wilde
|
|
Re: Unnecessary verbiage that wastes my time
On Fri, Aug 7, 2020 at 10:46 AM, Felix G. wrote:
but we get translations of translations, almost never what someone consciously designed.
- Because, at least to some extent, that's what happens when you translate one sense to another. There is no way to make a great deal of what "makes perfect sense" in the sensory idiom for which it was designed to have that perfect sense in another. All accessibility is a workaround. Not that I don't understand what you're saying, as I've said it, too, but it is not something you can ever entirely get away from. And you also say, " In the sighted world nobody would get away with it." And to a large extent, that's true, but that's not because it's "the sighted world" but because the things designed are being primarily designed with the sense of sight in mind. Given that the vast majority of the world can see, and that the medium itself is meant to be consumed via sight, that's what makes the most sense, wouldn't you say? Expecting websites and print media to be primarily designed with the blind in mind would be akin to expecting music to be composed primarily with the deaf in mind. [And that's not to excuse plain sloppiness and inaccessibility, either.] --
Brian - Windows 10 Pro, 64-Bit, Version 1909, Build 18363
A gentleman is one who never hurts anyone's feelings unintentionally.
~ Oscar Wilde
|
|
Re: Unnecessary verbiage that wastes my time
Hi! I've been reading along and I know this feeling. I often refer to it as the user experience that nobody designed. On the one hand there's a screen reader developer, on the other there's an app developer or web designer. They don't know each other, and yet their decisions converge on our experience of their products. In the sighted world nobody would get away with it, but we get translations of translations, almost never what someone consciously designed. Best, Felix
Am Do., 6. Aug. 2020 um 17:58 Uhr schrieb Brian Vogel <britechguy@gmail.com>:
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
On Thu, Aug 6, 2020 at 10:34 AM, Gene wrote:
People would never put up with a human reader announcing all this clutter.
I'd say that's absolutely true, but they'd probably also expect a human reader to say something about the fact that there is a figure/image present and what it illustrates as a part of the reading, unless the person their reading for has explicitly requested they only read the main text.
I actually feel your pain, and have had exactly that same feeling many, many times with multiple screen readers. I hope that someday there arrives AI sophisticated enough to screen read the way "your average sighted person" would likely take in looking at content. Heaven knows we virtually never look at scads of the navigation links and the like at the outset, but the main page content first.
But at this point in time, since a screen reader itself has no idea, really, of what it is you (any you) are looking for on a given page it offers "way too much" rather than allowing you to possibly miss the presence of something.
It would be nice if all of these sorts of things were arranged in "chunks" of announcements that fit a certain class, and that you could have the option of turning off the entire class with one checkbox, or going through the individual things announced and unchecking the ones you explicitly don't want while retaining the others. And do I ever know what a PITA that would be to code, and for the user to slog through, but in any really complex system where a high level of customization is wanted or needed, this is how its obtained.
--
Brian - Windows 10 Pro, 64-Bit, Version 1909, Build 18363
A gentleman is one who never hurts anyone's feelings unintentionally.
~ Oscar Wilde
|
|
Hello everyone, I already have a problem with Thunderbird solved. 1. In Thunderbird it is necessary to uncheck the status bar, 2. in Nvda Presentation of objects it is necessary to uncheck context help and notifications. Regards
-- Jarek
|
|
Re: Object Navigation - Where and How Do You Use It?
Hi Brian I understand you are using Object navigation in this case to gain knowledge of how to use it but I thought I would make you aware of the Virtual Review add-on. With Virtual Review installed, pressing NVDA+Ctrl+w when the About window is in focus, will open a temporary textual window containing the information from the About window you can’t access in situe using the keyboard. You can arrow around the virtual review window to read the info then press escape to dismiss it and return focus back to the About window itself. Cheers Chris from the In
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
From: Brian VogelSent: 06 August 2020 23:41 To: nvda@nvda.groups.ioSubject: Re: [nvda] Object Navigation - Where and How Do You Use It? On Thu, Aug 6, 2020 at 06:35 PM, Joseph Lee wrote: You can’t use keyboard commands to look at various system information displayed on that screen – you must use object navigation to read them.
- Thank you for this specific example. Again, this is very handy for me to have as I now have a specific location where playing with object navigation gets me a result I cannot get otherwise, and I've been told what that result would be. I just went through the list of items near the top of the About pane and got "status green" for each after it was read, and had no idea of exactly how I was supposed to (or even if I could) get to that information via NVDA. -- Brian - Windows 10 Pro, 64-Bit, Version 1909, Build 18363 A gentleman is one who never hurts anyone's feelings unintentionally. ~ Oscar Wilde
|
|
Re: Speech crackling/breaking up in latest NVDA
Oops, sorry, thought I was responding to someon in private.
For context, I checked Asus Live Update, and was able to get the
information that there were no new updates via the NVDA+b command.
The interface was otherwise inaccessible, even with review
commands.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
On 7/08/2020 2:09 pm, Sharni-Lee Ward
wrote:
I told you, the interface is inaccessible. I cannot press any
buttons to do anything with. I was lucky to get the information
I did.
On 7/08/2020 1:56 pm, Shaun Everiss
wrote:
Well you could always check and open live update and make
sure nothing is in the cue.
On 7/08/2020 11:12 am, Sharni-Lee
Ward wrote:
I already have Asus Live Update installed. It runs in the
background, right? It should have been doing its thing
during the whole year I've had this computer, right?
On 7/08/2020 9:05 am, Brian Vogel
wrote:
On Thu, Aug
6, 2020 at 06:43 PM, Sharni-Lee Ward wrote:
X507UAR
-
Support Page: https://www.asus.com/Laptops/ASUS-Laptop-X507UA/HelpDesk_download/
When I select the what's noted above in the CPU/BIOS
dropdown, along with Windows 10 for the OS, there are a
number of very recent updates, particularly recent is the
BIOS/UEFI update from June of this year. The most recent
Audio driver is noted as being from August 2019.
There is also a download
link for a utility called ICESound (that comes in a
ZIP file) from February 2020 that is described: It is
intelligent audio enhancement software that improves the
audio quality in sound experiences on laptops.
Most importantly, Asus has a system updater utility,
Asus
Live Update, that checks for all the device driver and
other updates that are applicable to your computer, and when
these are provided by the computer's manufacturer I strongly
recommend that they be used. They make keeping all the
essentials for your computer current much more easily than
anything else will. I'd download and install that and let
it do its thing as soon as is reasonably possible. I
suspect you'll have a bunch of things identified as needing
updates.
--
Brian - Windows
10 Pro, 64-Bit, Version 1909, Build 18363
A gentleman is one
who never hurts anyone's feelings unintentionally.
~
Oscar Wilde
|
|
Re: Speech crackling/breaking up in latest NVDA
I told you, the interface is inaccessible. I cannot press any
buttons to do anything with. I was lucky to get the information I
did.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
On 7/08/2020 1:56 pm, Shaun Everiss
wrote:
Well you could always check and open live update and make sure
nothing is in the cue.
On 7/08/2020 11:12 am, Sharni-Lee
Ward wrote:
I already have Asus Live Update installed. It runs in the
background, right? It should have been doing its thing during
the whole year I've had this computer, right?
On 7/08/2020 9:05 am, Brian Vogel
wrote:
On Thu, Aug 6,
2020 at 06:43 PM, Sharni-Lee Ward wrote:
X507UAR
-
Support Page: https://www.asus.com/Laptops/ASUS-Laptop-X507UA/HelpDesk_download/
When I select the what's noted above in the CPU/BIOS dropdown,
along with Windows 10 for the OS, there are a number of very
recent updates, particularly recent is the BIOS/UEFI update
from June of this year. The most recent Audio driver is noted
as being from August 2019.
There is also a download
link for a utility called ICESound (that comes in a ZIP
file) from February 2020 that is described: It is
intelligent audio enhancement software that improves the
audio quality in sound experiences on laptops.
Most importantly, Asus has a system updater utility, Asus
Live Update, that checks for all the device driver and
other updates that are applicable to your computer, and when
these are provided by the computer's manufacturer I strongly
recommend that they be used. They make keeping all the
essentials for your computer current much more easily than
anything else will. I'd download and install that and let it
do its thing as soon as is reasonably possible. I suspect
you'll have a bunch of things identified as needing updates.
--
Brian - Windows
10 Pro, 64-Bit, Version 1909, Build 18363
A gentleman is one who
never hurts anyone's feelings unintentionally.
~
Oscar Wilde
|
|
Re: Speech crackling/breaking up in latest NVDA
Another thing, on the asus page I linked to after chosing the uar
model, there is a bios update and utilities to do this, this is
recent and will effect all hardware, it may or may not fix issues
with the chips, there are chipset software updates to.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
On 7/08/2020 10:43 am, Sharni-Lee Ward
wrote:
System Model: VivoBook 15_ASUS Laptop X507UAR
I scrolled through the pages but couldn't find my sound driver
listed, and it said there were no problems found.
On 7/08/2020 7:49 am, Brian Vogel
wrote:
On Thu, Aug 6,
2020 at 05:38 PM, Sharni-Lee Ward wrote:
The make is Asus and I don't know off the top of my
head what the model is.
-
Unfortunately, then, I'm stuck. There are, literally, thousands
of Asus computer models, and without the specific model it's
impossible to determine what the most recent drivers Asus has
for a given computer are.
The only way I know of that you might be able to get the model
number, as what's provided varies by maker, is using the DXDIAG
command. Hit Winkey+R, enter DXDIAG in the open edit box, then
hit Enter. You'll get a message about needing to connect to the
internet to check certain things which it's fine to OK, then
after about 15-30 seconds a window will pop up with the title
DirectX Diagnostic Tool and it is open to its System tab. In
that tab, what's shown to the right of the label System
model is the model. There is also an Sound tab where the
driver information for your sound device (usually output device,
e.g., speakers/headphones) is shown. What's important is the
Date shown for the sound driver since you'd be checking on your
computer's Drivers & Software page to see if the driver they
offer is newer than what you have (also make a note of the
version number, too, as there are times when an updated package
is released, but the driver in it is the same version as an
earlier package).
--
Brian - Windows
10 Pro, 64-Bit, Version 1909, Build 18363
A gentleman is one who
never hurts anyone's feelings unintentionally.
~
Oscar Wilde
|
|
Re: Speech crackling/breaking up in latest NVDA
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
On 7/08/2020 10:43 am, Sharni-Lee Ward
wrote:
System Model: VivoBook 15_ASUS Laptop X507UAR
I scrolled through the pages but couldn't find my sound driver
listed, and it said there were no problems found.
On 7/08/2020 7:49 am, Brian Vogel
wrote:
On Thu, Aug 6,
2020 at 05:38 PM, Sharni-Lee Ward wrote:
The make is Asus and I don't know off the top of my
head what the model is.
-
Unfortunately, then, I'm stuck. There are, literally, thousands
of Asus computer models, and without the specific model it's
impossible to determine what the most recent drivers Asus has
for a given computer are.
The only way I know of that you might be able to get the model
number, as what's provided varies by maker, is using the DXDIAG
command. Hit Winkey+R, enter DXDIAG in the open edit box, then
hit Enter. You'll get a message about needing to connect to the
internet to check certain things which it's fine to OK, then
after about 15-30 seconds a window will pop up with the title
DirectX Diagnostic Tool and it is open to its System tab. In
that tab, what's shown to the right of the label System
model is the model. There is also an Sound tab where the
driver information for your sound device (usually output device,
e.g., speakers/headphones) is shown. What's important is the
Date shown for the sound driver since you'd be checking on your
computer's Drivers & Software page to see if the driver they
offer is newer than what you have (also make a note of the
version number, too, as there are times when an updated package
is released, but the driver in it is the same version as an
earlier package).
--
Brian - Windows
10 Pro, 64-Bit, Version 1909, Build 18363
A gentleman is one who
never hurts anyone's feelings unintentionally.
~
Oscar Wilde
|
|
Re: Speech crackling/breaking up in latest NVDA
Well you could always check and open live update and make sure
nothing is in the cue.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
On 7/08/2020 11:12 am, Sharni-Lee Ward
wrote:
I already have Asus Live Update installed. It runs in the
background, right? It should have been doing its thing during
the whole year I've had this computer, right?
On 7/08/2020 9:05 am, Brian Vogel
wrote:
On Thu, Aug 6,
2020 at 06:43 PM, Sharni-Lee Ward wrote:
X507UAR
-
Support Page: https://www.asus.com/Laptops/ASUS-Laptop-X507UA/HelpDesk_download/
When I select the what's noted above in the CPU/BIOS dropdown,
along with Windows 10 for the OS, there are a number of very
recent updates, particularly recent is the BIOS/UEFI update from
June of this year. The most recent Audio driver is noted as
being from August 2019.
There is also a download
link for a utility called ICESound (that comes in a ZIP
file) from February 2020 that is described: It is
intelligent audio enhancement software that improves the audio
quality in sound experiences on laptops.
Most importantly, Asus has a system updater utility, Asus
Live Update, that checks for all the device driver and
other updates that are applicable to your computer, and when
these are provided by the computer's manufacturer I strongly
recommend that they be used. They make keeping all the
essentials for your computer current much more easily than
anything else will. I'd download and install that and let it do
its thing as soon as is reasonably possible. I suspect you'll
have a bunch of things identified as needing updates.
--
Brian - Windows
10 Pro, 64-Bit, Version 1909, Build 18363
A gentleman is one who
never hurts anyone's feelings unintentionally.
~
Oscar Wilde
|
|